Hello, dear reader, I am going to discuss the harms of sexual restriction, which is when sexual expression is being suppressed by social norms or laws, leading to sexual repression and shame. By extension, I will argue for the benefits of sexual liberation, which is the freedom to express one’s sexuality and engage in sexual activity as one pleases.
While this may seem like an arcane, academic topic with no relevance to the life of the everyday person, it, in fact, has deep significance for the common person. This is because these two forces have a direct impact on the well-being of humans with sexual restriction and the repression that comes with it, damaging the mental health of people.
When you are finished reading, I hope that you, dear reader, will be able to see this and seek to challenge norms that shame or taboo expressions of sexuality or conversations about sex, both for your own welfare and that of those around you.
Sexual Repression and Its Effects
Sexual repression has been with us since the dawn of civilization. I imagine that you may have dealt with it yourself at least once in your life. It is the phenomenon in which a person consciously or unconsciously suppresses their sexual urges and cannot express their sexuality. It often evolves from consciously suppressing sexual urges to conform to the moral standards of others to unconscious repression, where sexual urges remain unconscious (Raypole, C. 2020, April 20).
This means that past sexual experience is often linked to negative emotions like anxiety and guilt. Sexual repression is linked to neuroticism, or poor mental health, in several ways. The first way is a common link in the form of sexual anxiety. Sexual anxiety is a condition where a person has anxiety around sexual activity, which can be caused by many things, including, but not limited to, lack of attraction or compatibility with a partner, poor body image, sexual dysfunction in self or partner, or a history of being sexually abused (Loggins B. 2026, March 16).
While all people have occasional worries, from time to time, about sex and their sexual performance, it can become deeply troubling, if not dealt with, and may lead to sexual repression, as failing to deal with general worries may lead to an emotional fallout.
Sexual Repression and Trauma
Sexual repression may be caused by societal or religious influences tabooing certain sexual desires, but traumatic experiences, like being raped, can also cause it. Obviously, traumatic experiences are linked to increased neuroticism as they cause intense feelings of distress and terror even long after the experience has passed.
The reason for this link is that traumatic experiences relating to sex often cause strong negative feelings like shame, and as such, the person who faced such trauma seeks to suppress thoughts related to sex to avoid the feelings such thoughts bring back up.
This phenomenon is not just true for trauma relating to sex, but all kinds of trauma. I sincerely hope you never had to go through such an experience, but it is still important to know about such a link.
Sexual Restriction
Finally, as stated earlier, being surrounded by a culture that taboos talking about sex whether in a family following strict religious doctrine or a society that frowns upon expressions of sexuality broadly is itself a driver of repression. Most of us, almost certainly have experienced this to some degree or another.
In every society, there are certain limits on sexual expression and consensual sexual activity, whether through law or general social norms. However, the amount of sexual openness present does vary across different societies. As such, the effect on mental health can be compared by looking at how open or restrictive it is when it comes to sexual matters.
For such a comparison, we can look at the difference between societies that accept homosexuality and those that taboo it. Societies that look down on homosexuality have higher rates of depression and anxiety for those who have attractions towards people of the same sex. (Kaprinis, S., & Charalampakis, A., 2025). This indicates that restrictive norms around sexuality harm the mental and physical well-being of humans.
Counter and Rebuttal
Now, why do these negative consequences for mental health matter in comparison to what some will argue to be the varied benefits of society restricting sexual activity and expressions of sexuality, such as preventing the spread of disease, clamping down on harassment and outright aggression, and maintaining the integrity of the family unit?
The spread of HIV and the eventual AIDs crisis was indeed the catalyst for the Sexual Counterrevolution (a movement to reverse the extremely open and permissive culture brought about by the Sexual Revolution, particularly the removal of stigma around homosexuality, premarital sex, and polyamory), however, sexual restrictiveness may actually not be the thing to credit, as diseases like AIDs became taken more seriously and condoms became more fashionable (Moran JS, Janes HR, Peterman TA, and Stone KM 1990 May). These safe-sex practices link to reducing the spread of disease.
This is evidenced by how states that implement comprehensive sex education have higher rates of safe-sex practices than states that have a more traditional, abstinence-focused curriculum, which taboo discussions around sex far more. (Bordogna, A. L., Coyle, A. C., Nallamothu, R., Manko, A. L., & Yen, R. W. 2023).
This is important because safe-sex practices reduce the spread of disease by people getting tested before engaging in sexual contact and using tools like condoms to reduce the spread of fluids (Healthline 2014, September 8).
This is a phenomenon that occurs independently of sexual restriction. On the point of preventing sexual harassment and coercive behavior, tabooing sex often does more harm than good, as restrictive norms around sex can lead to silencing victims (Aniebo, A. 2025, December 8).
This is exemplified by how purity culture often shames women for having sex before or outside of marriage, regardless of whether or not such intercourse was consensual. Finally, restrictiveness around human sexuality may actually damage familial relations. This is demonstrated in an article written by Carl Siciliano, about how homophobia leads to parents expelling their homosexual children from their homes and estranging them (2023, March 12).
This is clearly damaging to familial relations, as it causes parents and children to become mutually antagonistic. This indicates that sexual restriction may actually be harming the things its supporters claim to protect, far more than sexuality being expressed freely. My hope is that if you were previously in favor of sexual restriction and believed sexual liberation links to societal decay, I have convinced you otherwise.
Conclusion
Ultimately, sexual repression and the restrictive social norms that foster it are deeply damaging to the mental health of people, and the supposed benefits that such restrictions provide are not worth the harms they cause, as they can be provided in other ways that do not cause such damage. This damage, while it might seem to affect only the individual and therefore not be a serious issue, carries great gravity.
The reason is quite obvious: the individual and society are deeply interlinked, and you cannot affect one without affecting the other. This means that suppressing personal freedom and individuality inherently harms society to some degree, as its members cannot fully contribute to their fullest potential as they are not free to act as themselves.
It not only damages human flourishing but also hinders societal progress, and people are not able to make their individual contributions or express ideas that challenge the existing social order or culture.
Have I convinced you of the necessity of sexual freedom and why restrictions on sexual freedom should be looked at with as much skepticism as restrictions on other kinds of human freedom?
Free guide when you subscribe
Enjoyed this? Get Say It Out Loud, free.
Our menopause conversation guide: what to say to your doctor, your therapist and your partner, plus a symptom tracker. Subscribe free and it lands in your inbox, with $10 off the shop and new stories twice a month.
No spam. Unsubscribe in one click.
